Friday, June 21, 2013


21 JUNE 2013

The Court of Appeal held today that Pemakai Menoa IS part of NCR land, dismissing an appeal by the State Government of Sarawak against the judgment of Justice Datuk Yew Jen Kie in the case Director of Forest, Sarawak & Anor v TR Sandah ak Tabau & 7 Ors (Civil Appeal No Q-01-463-11).

In the High Court, the Plaintiffs had sued Kanowit Timber Company Sdn and the State Government for encroachment into their NCR land, including their pemakai menoa vide a timber licence issued by the State Government to Kanowit Timber Company Sdn Bhd. The defendants had argued that NCR should be restricted to the temuda covering an area of 2712 hactares, which had been cleared before 1958.  However, Justice Datuk Yew ruled in favour of the Plaintiffs, declaring that they were the rightful owners of the NCR land covering an area of 5512 hectares, including the pemakai menoa, and that the Defendants had unlawfully encroached into the Plaintiffs’ land. The State Government appealed against this decision.

In a unanimous judgment, the Court of Appeal comprising Justices Dato' Mohd Hishamudin bin Haji Mohd Yunus, Datuk Abdul Wahab bin Patail and  Dato' Balia Yusof bin Haji Wahi, following the landmark decisions of the Court of Appeal in Nor ak Nyawai and the Federal Court in Medeli bin Salleh, affirmed the decision of Justice Datuk Yew Jen Kie that pemakai menoa is NCR land and ordered costs against the State Government. Due to the significance of this case, the Court of Appeal will prepare a written decision for the benefit of future NCR claimants.

This decision of the Court of Appeal is a victory for the people of Sarawak who have been fighting for the recognition that their NCR lands is not limited to the temuda as the Government of Sarawak has been trying to claim. It remains to be seen whether the BN government will respect the decision of the Court of Appeal in carrying out perimeter surveys and whether they will be more respectful of the rights of the native people when issuing timber licences etc to logging and plantation companies.


1 comment:

Winston said...

The best way to wean the rural folks from dependence on hand-outs of the government is to find ways for them to increase their income.
That way, they won't be depending on the government and thus the influence of the latter will wan.